How the economies of the UK and Gibraltar are coping with Brexit

Is it business as usual?

LAST UPDATED: 12 Nov, 2016 @ 21:00
3
SHARE

Charles Gomez
Charles Gomez

“HOW many angels can dance on the head of a pin?” is said to have been the subject of scholastic debate in the Middle Ages and has since been used to denote wasteful discussion.

In these articles I have tried to be as evenhanded as possible and last week I put the spotlight on the monumental legal implications of removing European citizenship from 63,764,710 (plus 30,001 in Gibraltar) British nationals. Frankly, I do not see how it can be done.

Still, I also think that the UK will leave the EU, so what wasteful discussion do I want to talk about?

To quote Hillary Clinton’s husband “It’s the economy, stupid”.

The apocalyptic shrieks of the losing side in the June 23 referendum that the UK and Gibraltar economies would collapse have so far not materialised.

The UK still has one of the lowest unemployment rates in the EU (after Gibraltar) and consumer confidence remains high – things which cannot be said of much the rest of the EU.

I am not saying that the situation might not deteriorate and the Private Frazer doom-mongers might eventually be proved right, but I personally do not think so.

Gibraltar
Gibraltar

So, what has the EU done for Gibraltar and how has the Brexit referendum result affected this Britain in the Sun so far?

Bearing in mind that we joined the then European Community in 1973, Brussels’ impact on Gibraltar was often negligible and sometimes negative.

Thus, residents of Gibraltar were only able to vote in EU elections after Miss Denise Matthews took out court proceedings in 1998.

There has always been a strong suspicion that Spanish commissioners and MEP’s have used the European institutions to harass Gibraltar.

Whether this is true or not, is not for me to say openly (although I have my own views), but the behaviour of the until recently EU Commissioner responsible for Economic and Monetary Affairs, Joaquin Almunia and the MEP Ramon Jauregui should be noted.

EU-FLAGParticularly so given the sharp focus on Gibraltar whilst the EU has cheerfully given clean bills of health to competing jurisdictions including Dublin, Luxembourg and Andorra.

I for one believe that the strategy of the Spanish Foreign Ministry was to use the EU institutions as a rod for Gibraltar’s back and that the referendum result may have caught the Palacio de Santa Cruz by surprise for more reasons than one.

Scouring for economic data to see how things are going in Gibraltar I have spoken to many who, despite their worries, seem to back up the analysis that there is life after Brexit.

Indeed, the threat to Gibraltar’s economy and that of the entire Campo de Gibraltar in Spain may have little to do with a Brexit and very much to do with whether the new incumbent at the Spanish Foreign Ministry thinks that he or she can make use Britain’s perceived weakness to make the umpteenth attempt since 1704 to take over Gibraltar.

So, could the UK and Gibraltar continue to be havens from the gales that are buffeting other parts of the EU?

Only time will tell. The Prophets of Doom gleefully point at the claims that London based banks have drawn up contingency plans to leave the metropolis in case of something called a “hard Brexit”.

Of course, all companies are always making contingency plans – that is what competent company directors are paid for.

I spoke to a respected operator in the financial services industry in Gibraltar the other day.

He says that whilst he is of course concerned about the uncertainty going forward, he is even more worried about the over exuberant anti-Brexit narrative which could end up as a self-fulfilling prophecy.

I have had similar reports from people involved in tourism and real property.

As at early November 2016 therefore all indicators continue to point to business as usual and whilst over optimism is not recommended, neither is excessive pessimism.

In economic matters more than most, nobody can predict the future and regrettably, because we all crave for certainty, much of the current debate is speculative.



Gib Rocks - the magazine for Gibraltar

Subscribe: Olive Press news to your inbox

3 COMMENTS

  1. Brexit: leading banks set to pull out of UK early next year
    Anthony Browne, head of the British Bankers’ Association, warns that major lenders are poised to hit relocate button

    Nissan is an early sign of the downturns and the divisions Brexit could bring
    Car-maker puts investment plans on hold and the immigration debate intensifies – is this life outside the EU?
    It seems not.

  2. Pablo – since your posting Nissan has announced it will continue to invest in the UK with development and building of two new models.

    Major banks are not poised to move wholesale. Some are looking at rented office space in Luxembourg, Frankfurt and Dublin in order to be registered locally so they can continue their cross EU business unhindered. With 100% certainty they are not looking at relocating any teams to Spain.

    With regards to Brexit itself, the government has suffered one legal challenge already stating it should involve Parliament in a vote on the matter. Ironic really when the slogan of the leave campaign was to “take back control, and return sovereignty (to Parliment)”. The government has appealed this decision and it will be heard by the supreme court on 4th December. It is unlikely they will overturn the original ruling, but no one can be sure.

    Will Brexit actually happen ? Every day/week/month that goes by without triggering article 50 is weakning the case. We will see what happens in March 2017 – the date set by the government to trigger article 50.

  3. When were the wishes of ordinary British people ever treated with respect, if they dared to protest they were executed – the Peasants Revolt or more recently – Peterloo. Or the fat drunkard telling the police if they (the Jarrow Hunger Marchers) get out of control – shoot them.

    The elites were furious when the proles did’nt do as they had been instructed. They don’t want a Brexit, they will find a way to nullify the democratic result and if then the proles/peasants start to get serious, the uniformed goons wil just love to open fire – and morons think they live in a democracy LOL.

HAVE YOUR SAY...